Discover the ultimate blueprint for hiring & keeping top talent

The Risks of Accepting a Counteroffer

Share on LinkedIn

The Counteroffer Conundrum: The Ugly Truth

When you’re a valuable employee and you decide to resign, your current employer may surprise you with a counter offer. While this might initially make you feel flattered, it’s important to approach counteroffers with caution and consider the potential consequences before making a decision. Research shows that accepting a counteroffer can often lead to negative outcomes and may not be in your best interest. Let’s uncover the ugly truth about accepting counteroffers.


1. The Statistics Don’t Lie

According to Christian & Timbers, a leading Performance Consulting firm, employees who accept counteroffers typically end up leaving the company within the next six months. The National Association of Personnel Consultants supports this statistic, stating that over 80% of employees who accept counteroffers are no longer with the same company after six months. This highlights the importance of understanding whether accepting a counteroffer will provide a permanent solution or merely serve as a temporary fix. Remember why you considered leaving the company in the first place and carefully evaluate the motives behind the counteroffer.


2. The Company’s Motives

Seth O. Harris, a technologist, and partner at Christian & Timbers, explains that companies usually make counteroffers to protect themselves, the stability of the company, and ongoing projects. Counteroffers are often made to avoid the risk of losing productivity or revenue after an employee’s departure. However, if you were truly valued, why weren’t you offered a promotion or higher salary before you handed in your resignation? Counteroffers can be seen as nothing more than stall tactics, giving your employer time to find a replacement.


3. The Trust Factor

Accepting a counteroffer can raise questions about your loyalty. Once you’ve revealed your intention to leave, your status as a “team member” may be compromised, and you may find yourself excluded from the inner circle of the company. The trust between you and your employer may be broken, and your commitment could be questioned going forward.


4. The Damage to Your Reputation

Another factor to consider is the impact on your professional reputation. If you accept a job offer from another company and then back out after accepting, you not only disappoint the recruiter but also damage your own credibility. The recruiter may no longer support you, and the employer you turned down is unlikely to consider you again. Additionally, if word spreads within your industry, it could hinder your chances of finding future employment.


5. Unethical Negotiation Tactics

It’s important to emphasize that intentionally seeking a counteroffer as a negotiation tactic is unethical and risky. Conducting a job search with the sole intention of using another offer to leverage a raise within your current company can have severe consequences. The likelihood of this strategy backfiring is high, and the potential damage to your professional reputation is not worth the risk.


6. Weighing the Pros and Cons

If you do decide to accept a counteroffer, ensure that all agreements are clearly stated in writing and meet your expectations. Don’t be afraid to negotiate for additional perks, benefits, or a higher salary. However, remember that accepting a counteroffer doesn’t guarantee that the original issues that prompted your decision to leave will be resolved. It’s crucial to prioritize your long-term career growth and make choices that align with your professional goals.

Reflecting on personal experiences, have you ever accepted a counteroffer, only to realize that you should have taken the other position when you had the chance? Share your insights and lessons learned.


Anjela Mangrum, the founder of Mangrum Career Solutions, is a trusted authority in executive recruitment for the manufacturing industry! She’s dedicated to matching top-tier candidates with rewarding opportunities in the field. Connect with her on LinkedIn and join the MCS LinkedIn group for the latest in manufacturing recruitment news and trends. Let’s partner in your hiring success!